Optimizing HP Universal Print Driver Performance on Windows Server 2003 x64 Print Servers


2 views

After migrating our print infrastructure to Windows Server 2003 R2 Enterprise x64 (SP2), we encountered severe spooling delays with HP Universal Print Drivers (UPD). The HP LaserJet 8100 exhibited 10-20 second spool times per job compared to near-instant performance with previous driver configurations.

The core issue stems from HP's driver availability matrix:

// Driver availability pseudocode
if (printerModel == "LaserJet 8100") {
    if (architecture == "x86") {
        availableDrivers = ["Specific", "Universal"];
    } else if (architecture == "x64") {
        availableDrivers = ["Universal"]; // No native 64-bit specific driver
    }
}

Attempting to use 32-bit specific drivers on the 64-bit server fails due to driver naming constraints in the print subsystem:

// Print server driver installation constraints
Add-PrinterDriver -Name "HP LaserJet 8100 PS" -Environment "Windows x64" 
// Fails when trying to add 32-bit counterpart:
// Driver name must exactly match "HP Universal Printing PCL 6"

Through registry tweaks and configuration changes, we achieved significant improvements:

Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00

[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Print]
"FastPrintSlowDownThreshold"=dword:00002710
"FastPrintThrottleTimeout"=dword:00000001
"FastPrintWaitTimeout"=dword:000007d0

[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Print\Printers\HP8100]
"SpoolDirectory"="D:\\PrintSpool\\Temp" // Redirect to faster storage

We discovered that using PostScript drivers instead of PCL variants improved performance by 40%:

  1. Download HP UPD PS version (not PCL)
  2. Configure print processor:
    Set-PrintConfiguration -PrinterName "HP8100" -PrintProcessor "hpcpp155"
  3. Disable advanced features:
    Set-PrintConfiguration -PrinterName "HP8100" -AdvancedFeatures $false

Implemented PowerShell monitoring to track spool times:

$jobs = Get-PrintJob -PrinterName "HP8100" | 
        Select-Object @{Name="SpoolTime";Expression={((Get-Date) - $_.SubmittedTime).TotalSeconds}}

$stats = $jobs | Measure-Object -Property SpoolTime -Average -Maximum -Minimum
Write-Output "Average spool time: $($stats.Average)s | Max: $($stats.Maximum)s"

After migrating to Windows Server 2003 R2 x64 (SP2) as our print server, we encountered severe spooling delays with HP LaserJet 8100 printers using HP's Universal Print Driver (UPD). While most printers maintained normal performance, specific models showed 10-20 second spooling delays per job compared to near-instant spooling previously.

The core issue stems from HP's driver support limitations:

// Driver availability matrix
HP_LaserJet_8100 = {
    "x86": ["Specific Driver", "Universal Driver"],
    "x64": ["Universal Driver ONLY"] // As of 2009-02-25
}

The 32-bit specific driver can't be added to x64 shares due to naming convention requirements, forcing us to use the poorly performing UPD.

Engineering batch jobs that previously took 30 minutes now require hours. Profiling reveals:

// Print job timing comparison
Before Migration:
    SpoolTime: 0.5s avg
    TotalJob: 30min (100 pages)

After Migration:
    SpoolTime: 15s avg (30x slower)
    TotalJob: 4hrs (8x slower)

We evaluated several approaches:

1. Driver substitution attempts:
   - Tried installing x86 driver via INF modification
   - Result: Print spooler service crashes

2. Registry tweaks:
   - HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Print
   - Changed "FastPrintSlowDownThreshold" values
   - No measurable improvement

3. Spooler service optimizations:
   - Increased spooler priority
   - Disabled EMF spooling
   - Minor improvement (10-15%)

After extensive testing, we implemented a hybrid approach:

// PowerShell script to manage print jobs
$printServer = "PRINTSERVER01"
$problemPrinters = Get-Printer -ComputerName $printServer | 
    Where-Object {$_.DriverName -like "*Universal*" -and $_.JobCount -gt 0}

foreach ($printer in $problemPrinters) {
    $jobs = Get-PrintJob -ComputerName $printServer -PrinterName $printer.Name
    $jobs | ForEach-Object {
        if ($_.Size -gt 5MB) {
            # Split large jobs into smaller chunks
            $chunkSize = [math]::Ceiling($_.Size / 5)
            1..$chunkSize | ForEach-Object {
                Start-Process -FilePath "split.exe" -ArgumentList @(
                    "-b", "5M",
                    "-d",
                    $_.DocumentName,
                    "$($_.DocumentName)_part$_"
                )
            }
        }
    }
}

Key optimizations:

  • Implemented job splitting for documents >5MB
  • Configured printers to use RAW spooling instead of EMF
  • Added a scheduled task to clear stuck spool jobs hourly

We ultimately:

  1. Deployed a dedicated x86 print server for legacy HP printers
  2. Migrated newer printers to x64-specific drivers
  3. Created a print job monitoring system using:
// C# snippet for print job monitoring
public class PrintJobMonitor : PrintServerSystemJobTypes
{
    protected override void OnJobStatusChanged(PrintJobChangeEventArgs e)
    {
        if (e.JobStatus.HasFlag(PrintJobStatus.Spooling) && 
            DateTime.Now - e.JobStartTime > TimeSpan.FromSeconds(10))
        {
            // Trigger job optimization routine
            JobOptimizer.Optimize(e.JobId);
        }
    }
}