When working with network configurations on Linux systems, particularly Ubuntu, you might encounter an unexpected behavior with the arp command. The issue manifests when attempting to delete an ARP cache entry:

$ sudo arp -avn
? (10.10.7.30) at 00:cc:cc:bb:dd:86 [ether] on eth0

$ sudo arp --delete 10.10.7.30

$ sudo arp -avn
? (10.10.7.30) at  [ether] on eth0

This behavior occurs because the Linux kernel maintains the ARP cache entry structure but marks it as incomplete when deleted. The entry isn't immediately purged from the kernel's ARP table but instead enters this transitional state.

The incomplete state indicates:

• The kernel remembers the IP address was previously resolved
• The MAC address association has been invalidated
• The system will attempt to resolve the address again if needed

For complete removal of ARP cache entries, try these alternative methods:

Method 1: Using iproute2

sudo ip neigh del 10.10.7.30 dev eth0

Method 2: Flushing the Entire ARP Cache

sudo ip neigh flush all

Method 3: Using System Restart

For persistent issues, consider restarting network services:

sudo systemctl restart networking

The behavior can be influenced by several kernel parameters:

# Check current ARP settings
cat /proc/sys/net/ipv4/neigh/eth0/gc_stale_time
cat /proc/sys/net/ipv4/neigh/eth0/base_reachable_time

# Temporarily modify parameters (example)
sudo sysctl -w net.ipv4.neigh.eth0.gc_stale_time=30

Here's a bash script to properly clean ARP entries:

#!/bin/bash
# Clear specific ARP entry
IP_TO_CLEAR="10.10.7.30"
INTERFACE="eth0"

# First try iproute2 method
sudo ip neigh del $IP_TO_CLEAR dev $INTERFACE 2>/dev/null

# Verify removal
arp_output=$(arp -an | grep $IP_TO_CLEAR)
if [ -n "$arp_output" ]; then
    # Fall back to alternative methods if needed
    echo "Entry still exists, trying alternative methods..."
    sudo arp -d $IP_TO_CLEAR
    sudo ip neigh flush $IP_TO_CLEAR
fi

The behavior varies across Linux distributions and kernel versions. Key factors affecting ARP cache management include:

• Kernel version (especially networking subsystem)
• Network driver implementation
• System configuration (particularly /proc/sys/net/ipv4 settings)
• Concurrent network activity

For Ubuntu 10.04 specifically, this behavior was more prevalent due to older networking stack implementations. Newer kernels tend to handle ARP cache management more efficiently.

---

When working with ARP cache management on Linux systems, you might encounter this puzzling behavior:

$ sudo arp -avn
? (10.10.7.30) at 00:cc:cc:bb:dd:86 [ether] on eth0
...
$ sudo arp --delete 10.10.7.30
$ sudo arp -avn
? (10.10.7.30) at  [ether] on eth0

Instead of completely removing the ARP entry, the system marks it as "incomplete". This occurs because the Linux kernel maintains the ARP cache differently than you might expect.

The Linux kernel's ARP implementation has a specific behavior pattern:

• When you delete an entry with arp --delete, the kernel doesn't immediately purge it
• Instead, it marks the entry for potential reuse
• The entry will eventually time out if no new ARP requests are received

If you need to completely remove an ARP entry, you have several options:

# Method 1: Use iproute2 tools (preferred)
sudo ip neigh del 10.10.7.30 dev eth0

# Method 2: Flush the entire ARP cache
sudo ip -s -s neigh flush all

# Method 3: Alternative arp command syntax
sudo arp -d 10.10.7.30

The Linux kernel maintains ARP entries in this way for several technical reasons:

• Performance optimization - avoids unnecessary ARP resolution for frequently contacted hosts
• Network stability - prevents ARP storms when hosts reconnect
• State tracking - maintains connection state information for diagnostic purposes

When writing scripts that manage ARP entries, you should:

#!/bin/bash
# Proper ARP management in scripts
TARGET_IP="10.10.7.30"
INTERFACE="eth0"

# Completely remove ARP entry
ip neigh del "$TARGET_IP" dev "$INTERFACE"

# Verify removal
if ip neigh show | grep -q "$TARGET_IP"; then
    echo "Warning: ARP entry still exists"
else
    echo "ARP entry successfully removed"
fi

To observe ARP state transitions in real-time:

# Watch ARP table changes
sudo watch -n 1 'ip -4 neigh show nud all'

# Alternative using arpwatch
sudo arpwatch -i eth0

You can modify ARP behavior through sysctl parameters:

# View current ARP settings
sysctl -a | grep arp

# Adjust ARP timeout (default 60 seconds)
sudo sysctl -w net.ipv4.neigh.default.gc_stale_time=30