When deploying SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) systems, CentOS has been the industry standard for years. As a downstream rebuild of RHEL, it offers:
- 10-year lifecycle with Long-Term Support (LTS)
- Strict version-locked package management (yum/dnf)
- Enterprise-grade security updates backported to stable versions
- SELinux policies pre-configured for industrial environments
# Example of CentOS's stable package approach
sudo yum install epel-release
sudo yum --enablerepo=epel install modbus-tools
# Version will remain stable for the OS lifecycle
Fedora serves as upstream for RHEL/CentOS and provides:
- Newest kernel features (like real-time patches)
- Faster hardware support through recent drivers
- Short 13-month lifecycle per release
- Modern development tools (e.g., Podman 4.x vs CentOS's 3.x)
// Fedora's newer libiec61850 library example
#include
// Typically 1-2 versions ahead of CentOS's backported packages
For industrial control systems, key differentiators include:
Factor | CentOS | Fedora |
---|---|---|
Kernel RT Patches | Pre-tested backlog | Latest untested |
OPC UA Stack | Certified versions | Development branches |
Fieldbus Support | Stable backports | Experimental drivers |
If transitioning from Fedora to CentOS for SCADA:
- Test containers first using Podman:
podman run -it --rm quay.io/centos/centos:stream9 dnf install plc-tools
- Rebuild custom RPMs with:
mock -r epel-9-x86_64 rebuild package.src.rpm
- Validate SELinux policies:
audit2allow -a -M scada_policy
Consider Fedora if your SCADA deployment requires:
- Prototyping with unreleased industrial protocols
- Testing hardware with very new chipsets
- Developing next-gen IIoT applications
Example for experimental PROFINET:
# Fedora's COPR often has newer stack
sudo dnf copr enable industrial/profinet
sudo dnf install libprofinet-dev
When deploying SCADA solutions, the primary advantage of CentOS (now Rocky/AlmaLinux) over Fedora lies in its enterprise-grade stability. While Fedora serves as an excellent bleeding-edge development platform, its 6-month release cycle introduces challenges for long-term industrial deployments:
# Example systemd service stability check (relevant for SCADA daemons)
# CentOS maintains consistent systemd versions throughout its lifecycle
$ systemctl --version | head -1
systemd 219 (CentOS 7)
systemd 239 (CentOS 8 Stream)
# Fedora frequently updates systemd
$ systemctl --version | head -1
systemd 253 (Fedora 38)
SCADA systems often require specific library versions that must remain stable for decades. CentOS's yum/dnf behavior differs significantly:
# CentOS prioritizes stability over new features
$ sudo yum install modbus-tools
--> Will maintain same major version throughout OS lifecycle
# Fedora's frequent updates may break legacy dependencies
$ sudo dnf install libplctag
--> May receive incompatible updates during system upgrades
Industrial hardware often relies on out-of-tree drivers that require kernel consistency. The CentOS kernel policy ensures long-term ABI stability:
# Checking kernel version consistency
$ uname -r
3.10.0-1160.102.1.el7.x86_64 (CentOS 7 - maintained for 10+ years)
6.5.12-200.fc38.x86_64 (Fedora 38 - changes every few months)
Consider a Ignition SCADA deployment using OPC UA:
# CentOS installation script (stable environment)
#!/bin/bash
# Add EPEL for industrial packages
sudo yum install -y epel-release
sudo yum install -y \
ignition-edge \
opcua-tools \
python2-modbus-tk # Maintains Python 2 compatibility
# Versus Fedora potential issues
sudo dnf install -y ignition-edge
# May force Python 3-only dependencies breaking legacy integrations
For existing Fedora developers, consider these transition strategies:
# Using Podman to containerize Fedora-developed components
podman run -dt --name scada-dev \
-v ./project:/code:z \
registry.access.redhat.com/ubi8/ubi:latest \
/code/deploy.sh
# Maintaining development on Fedora but targeting CentOS/RHEL builds
# In your spec files:
%if 0%{?rhel} || 0%{?centos}
BuildRequires: modbus-libs >= 1.5
%else
BuildRequires: libmodbus >= 3.1
%endif
Fedora remains superior for:
- Prototyping with cutting-edge industrial IoT protocols
- Developing containerized SCADA components
- Testing compatibility with future RHEL/CentOS versions
# Example of Fedora's advantage for prototyping
sudo dnf install -y \
opc-ua-iiot-demo \
mqtt-prometheus-bridge \
node-red-contrib-opcua