When working with LVM in production environments, you might encounter situations where VG free space appears sufficient but extensions fail with:

lvextend -L +50G /dev/data/lvm2
Insufficient suitable allocatable extents for logical volume lvm2: 10783 more required

The key insight comes from examining the PV distribution:

PV /dev/sdb   VG data  lvm2 [279.36 GiB / 119.36 GiB free]
PV /dev/sdc   VG data  lvm2 [558.88 GiB / 7.88 GiB free]

The issue arises because LVM cannot find contiguous space matching the allocation policy requirements. The 127GB free space is fragmented across multiple PVs.

Solution 1: Explicit PV Specification

Force allocation from the PV with sufficient contiguous space:

lvextend -L +50G /dev/data/lvm2 /dev/sdb

Solution 2: Changing Allocation Policy

Modify the volume group to use contiguous allocation:

vgchange --alloc contiguous data
lvextend -L +50G /dev/data/lvm2

Solution 3: Manual PE Allocation

Check available PEs and allocate precisely:

pvdisplay -m /dev/sdb
lvextend -l +30720 /dev/data/lvm2 /dev/sdb

For complex scenarios, consider these diagnostics:

# Check PE size and count
vgdisplay -v data

# Verify allocation policies
lvdisplay -m /dev/data/lvm2

# Check for volume group metadata issues
vgcfgrestore --list data

Best practices for LVM management:

• Maintain at least 5-10% free space in each PV
• Use similar-sized PVs when possible
• Consider --alloc contiguous for performance-critical volumes
• Monitor fragmentation with lvdisplay -m

# Example monitoring command
watch -n 60 'lvdisplay -m /dev/data/lvm2 | grep -A5 "Logical volume"'

---

When working with LVM (Logical Volume Manager) on Linux systems, you might encounter the frustrating "Insufficient suitable allocatable extents" error even when your volume group shows adequate free space. Let's examine a real-world scenario:

# vgs output showing 127.24GB free
VG    #PV #LV #SN Attr   VSize   VFree  
data    2   2   0 wz--l- 838.24g 127.24g

# Yet lvextend fails for +50GB request
lvextend -L +50G /dev/data/lvm2
Insufficient suitable allocatable extents for logical volume lvm2: 10783 more required

The error occurs because LVM requires contiguous physical extents to extend a logical volume. Even with sufficient total free space, if the available extents are fragmented across physical volumes, the operation will fail.

In our case, examining pvs reveals:

PV         VG    Fmt  Attr PSize   PFree  
/dev/sdb   data  lvm2 a--  279.36g 119.36g
/dev/sdc   data  lvm2 a--  558.88g   7.88g

The 127GB free space is unevenly distributed - 119GB on /dev/sdb and only 7.88GB on /dev/sdc. The system can't find 50GB of contiguous space on a single PV.

Solution 1: Specify the Physical Volume

Force the extension to use the PV with sufficient space:

lvextend -L +50G /dev/data/lvm2 /dev/sdb

Solution 2: Use --alloc anywhere Option

Allow non-contiguous allocation (may impact performance):

lvextend -L +50G --alloc anywhere /dev/data/lvm2

Solution 3: Rebalance Your VG

Move existing extents to create contiguous space:

# First check movable extents
pvmove --alloc anywhere -n lvm2 -i /dev/sdc

# Then perform the actual move
pvmove /dev/sdc /dev/sdb

# Now try extending again
lvextend -L +50G /dev/data/lvm2

To avoid this situation in the future:

• Plan your storage allocation carefully from the beginning
• Use similar-sized physical volumes in your VG
• Consider using thin provisioning if your workload allows it
• Regularly monitor your PV free space distribution

For complex scenarios, you might need to examine extent allocation in detail:

# Show physical segment distribution
pvdisplay -m

# Detailed LV mapping
lvs -v --segments /dev/data/lvm2

Remember that LVM operations can be risky - always ensure you have proper backups before making significant changes to your storage configuration.