Apache Memory Optimization: Calculating Max Concurrent Threads Based on VIRT vs RES Under Heavy Load


12 views

When analyzing Apache's memory usage on a high-traffic Debian server, we need to distinguish between two critical metrics:

VIRT - Virtual memory (180MB per process in this case)
RES  - Resident memory (16MB per process)

The server has 4GB RAM with no swap. We face two potential calculation approaches:

1. VIRT-based: 4000MB / 180MB ≈ 22 processes
2. RES-based: 4000MB / 16MB ≈ 256 processes

For capacity planning, RES is the correct metric to use because:

  • VIRT includes memory-mapped files and shared libraries
  • Only RES represents actual physical RAM consumption
  • Shared memory between Apache processes reduces actual footprint

Here's how to set appropriate limits in Apache's configuration:


    StartServers            5
    MinSpareServers         5
    MaxSpareServers        10
    MaxRequestWorkers     250  # Conservative buffer below 256
    MaxConnectionsPerChild 10000

Use this bash command to track real memory usage:

watch -n 5 "ps -ylC apache2 --sort:rss | awk '{sum+=\$8; count++} END {print \"Total RSS:\",sum/1024,\"MB\"; print \"Avg RSS:\",sum/count/1024,\"MB\"}'"

To further reduce memory footprint:

# In php.ini (if using PHP-FPM)
pm = dynamic
pm.max_children = 50
pm.start_servers = 5
pm.min_spare_servers = 5
pm.max_spare_servers = 10

While RES is primary, monitor VIRT for:

  • Memory leaks (continuously growing VIRT)
  • Unexpected large allocations
  • Shared library overhead

When analyzing Apache's memory consumption on a Debian server with heavy traffic, we observe two key metrics:

  • VIRT (Virtual Memory): 180MB per process - represents the total address space allocated
  • RES (Resident Memory): 16MB per process - shows actual physical RAM usage

The fundamental question arises when determining maximum Apache threads:

# Two possible calculation approaches:
1. Based on VIRT: 4000MB / 180MB ≈ 22 processes
2. Based on RES: 4000MB / 16MB ≈ 256 processes

In practice, Linux memory management is more nuanced:

  • VIRT includes memory-mapped files and shared libraries
  • RES shows the actual physical RAM being used
  • Shared memory segments are counted only once in RES

A more accurate approach considers:

# Sample calculation accounting for shared memory
shared_mem = 80MB  # Apache shared libraries
per_process = 16MB
max_processes = (total_ram - shared_mem) / per_process

# With 4GB RAM:
(4096 - 80) / 16 ≈ 251 processes

Adjust your Apache MPM settings accordingly:

# In /etc/apache2/mods-available/mpm_prefork.conf
<IfModule mpm_prefork_module>
    StartServers            5
    MinSpareServers         5
    MaxSpareServers        10
    MaxRequestWorkers     250  # Safe value for 4GB system
    MaxConnectionsPerChild  0  # Or set to recycle after X requests
</IfModule>

Implement these verification steps:

# Install necessary tools
sudo apt-get install htop sysstat

# Monitor shared memory usage
pmap -x $(pgrep apache2 | head -1) | grep -i shared

# Track actual memory pressure
vmstat -SM 5  # Shows in megabytes every 5 seconds

Consider these additional measures:

  • Implement a swap file (even on SSD systems)
  • Enable KeepAlive with conservative timeout settings
  • Consider using mod_cache for static content