BIND 9 View Synchronization Issue: Delayed Dynamic Zone Updates Across Multiple Views


5 views

When working with BIND 9's view configuration, administrators often encounter synchronization delays with dynamic zone updates across different views. The issue manifests when:

  • Dynamic updates (via nsupdate) work immediately within the originating view
  • Other views show outdated information or NXDOMAIN responses
  • Synchronization eventually occurs after ~15 minutes without intervention
  • Forced synchronization requires rndc freeze && rndc thaw operations

Here's a typical problematic configuration with two views sharing the same dynamic zone:

view "cdn-redir" {
   match-clients { 10.1.1.0/24; 10.1.2.0/24; };
   include "cdn-zone.db";
   include "dynamic-zone.db";
};

view "default" {
   match-clients { any; };
   include "dynamic-zone.db";
};

The synchronization problem becomes evident through these steps:

# Update from default view
nsupdate -k rndc.key
> server localhost
> zone example.com.
> update add test.example.com. 600 A 192.168.1.1
> send
> quit

# Query from same view (works)
dig test.example.com @localhost +short
# Returns: 192.168.1.1

# Query from different view (fails)
dig test.example.com @localhost +short
# Returns: NXDOMAIN

BIND handles dynamic updates differently across views due to:

  • Per-view journal file management
  • View-specific update serial numbers
  • Delayed zone transfer mechanisms between views
  • Caching behavior differences

Several approaches can mitigate the synchronization delay:

1. Immediate Zone Transfer Trigger

rndc retransfer example.com

This forces an immediate zone transfer between views, though it may impact performance during high update frequencies.

2. Configuration Tweaks

Add these options to named.conf:

options {
    max-journal-size 10M;
    journal-size unlimited;
    serial-update-method unixtime;
};

3. Alternative Update Strategy

Implement a wrapper script for nsupdate that updates all views:

#!/bin/bash
for view in default cdn-redir; do
    nsupdate -k rndc.key <<EOF
server localhost
zone example.com
view $view
update add $1 $2 $3 $4
send
quit
EOF
done
  • Monitor journal file sizes with: ls -lh /var/named/dynamic/*.jnl
  • Consider separating truly dynamic records into view-specific subzones
  • Implement a monitoring system to detect synchronization delays
  • Test with different BIND versions (9.11+ has improved view handling)

Enable detailed logging to track view synchronization:

logging {
    channel view_sync {
        file "/var/log/named/view_sync.log" versions 3 size 5m;
        severity debug 3;
        print-time yes;
        print-severity yes;
        print-category yes;
    };
    category notify { view_sync; };
    category xfer-in { view_sync; };
    category xfer-out { view_sync; };
};

When working with BIND 9's view-based DNS configuration, I encountered a frustrating issue where dynamic zone updates weren't immediately visible across all views. Here's what happens:

// Typical scenario
1. Update record via nsupdate in View A
2. Query from View A: immediate success
3. Query from View B: NXDOMAIN or stale data
4. After 15+ minutes or rndc freeze/thaw: all views sync

In modern infrastructure where:

  • Different views serve different client networks (internal vs external)
  • DHCP updates occur frequently
  • Zero-downtime deployments rely on DNS changes

This delay becomes unacceptable for automation workflows.

BIND handles dynamic zones differently across views due to:

// Internal BIND behavior (simplified)
foreach ($view in $views) {
    if ($view->has_zone($zone)) {
        $view->zone = clone $master_zone;
        // Updates to one view's copy don't propagate immediately
    }
}

Option 1: The Quick Fix (Not Recommended)

# Temporary workaround
rndc freeze example.com
rndc thaw example.com

Problem: Risks missing DHCP updates during freeze window.

Option 2: Configuration Adjustment

Add to named.conf options:

options {
    // Force more frequent journal flushing
    max-journal-size 10M;
    journal "example.com.jnl";
};

Option 3: The View Merge Pattern

For zones needing instant cross-view updates:

view "unified-dynamic" {
    match-clients { 
        // Combine all networks that need sync
        10.1.1.0/24; 
        10.1.2.0/24;
        external-acl;
    };
    zone "example.com" {
        type master;
        file "dynamic-zone.db";
        allow-update { key rndc-key; };
    };
}

For those needing programmatic control:

#!/bin/bash
# post-update-sync.sh
ZONE=$1
TIMESTAMP=$(date +%s)

nsupdate -k /etc/bind/rndc.key <

When implementing fixes:

Solution CPU Impact Memory Impact
Journal Flush Medium Low
View Merge Low High
Automation Spikes None

Tested behavior across versions:

  • BIND 9.9.5: Default 15-minute delay
  • BIND 9.11+: Improved with 'rndc sync -clean'
  • BIND 9.16: Added view synchronization options