Linked Clone vs Full Clone in Virtualization: Key Differences and Practical Use Cases for Developers


2 views

The fundamental difference between linked and full clones lies in their disk storage behavior:

// Conceptual representation of clone types
class VMClone {
  constructor(baseVM) {
    this.baseVM = baseVM;
  }
}

class FullClone extends VMClone {
  constructor(baseVM) {
    super(baseVM);
    this.storage = this.copyAllDisks(); // Independent copy
  }
}

class LinkedClone extends VMClone {
  constructor(baseVM) {
    super(baseVM);
    this.storage = new DeltaDisk(baseVM.disk); // Depends on parent
  }
}

Linked clones are particularly useful in development environments:

  • CI/CD Pipelines: Creating identical test environments quickly
    # Jenkins pipeline example using linked clones
    pipeline {
      agent any
      stages {
        stage('Test') {
          steps {
            parallel {
              stage('Unit Tests') {
                steps { sh 'vm-clone --linked --name unit-test-${BUILD_ID}' }
              }
              stage('Integration Tests') {
                steps { sh 'vm-clone --linked --name int-test-${BUILD_ID}' }
              }
            }
          }
        }
      }
    }
    
  • Classroom/Training: When you need multiple identical VMs with minimal storage overhead
  • Quick Prototyping: Spinning up temporary environments for feature testing

Full clones are essential when:

  • You need complete isolation from the parent VM
    // PowerShell example creating a production clone
    New-VM -Name "ProdServer-$(Get-Date -Format yyyyMMdd)" 
           -VM "TemplateVM" 
           -CloneType Full 
           -Datastore "SSD_Cluster"
    
  • Long-term deployment is required (linked clones break if parent is modified)
  • Performance-critical applications where delta disks might introduce overhead
Metric Linked Clone Full Clone
Creation Time Seconds Minutes to Hours
Storage Usage Minimal (MBs-GBs) Full VM size (GBs-TBs)
I/O Performance Slightly slower (depends on parent) Native performance

Here's how to manage clones programmatically using libvirt:

import libvirt

conn = libvirt.open("qemu:///system")
base_vm = conn.lookupByName("base-ubuntu")

# Create linked clone
linked_xml = f"""
<disk type='file' device='disk'>
  <driver name='qemu' type='qcow2'/>
  <source file='/var/lib/libvirt/images/linked-clone.qcow2'/>
  <backingStore type='file'>
    <format type='qcow2'/>
    <source file='{base_vm.XMLDesc()}'/>
  </backingStore>
</disk>
"""

# Create full clone
full_clone = base_vm.createCloneXML("""
<domain>
  <name>full-clone</name>
  <memory>2097152</memory>
  <!-- Full disk copy will occur -->
</domain>
""", libvirt.VIR_DOMAIN_CLONE_FULL)

When working with virtualization platforms like VMware or VirtualBox, you'll encounter two primary cloning methods:

  • Full Clone: Creates completely independent copy of the source VM including all virtual disks
  • Linked Clone: Creates a dependent VM that shares virtual disks with the parent VM

Here's how storage allocation differs between the two approaches:


// Example storage allocation in VMware API
if (cloneType == "FULL") {
    diskMode = "independent_persistent";
    allocationPolicy = "allocateAll";
} else {
    diskMode = "nonpersistent";
    allocationPolicy = "thinProvisioned";
}

Linked clones typically offer:

  • Faster creation time (often 90% quicker than full clones)
  • Reduced storage requirements (sharing common base disk)
  • Potential read performance overhead due to disk chain traversal

When to Use Full Clones

Production environments where:

  • Complete isolation is required (security/compliance)
  • The VM needs to be portable (no parent dependency)
  • Performance is critical (no disk chain overhead)

When to Use Linked Clones

Development/testing scenarios like:

  • Creating multiple test environments from a gold image
  • Temporary sandbox environments
  • CI/CD pipeline where quick VM provisioning is needed

Here's how you might automate clone creation using PowerShell with VMware:


# Full clone example
New-VM -Name "ProdWebServer01" -VM "TemplateWS2019" 
       -Datastore "SAN-01" -DiskStorageFormat Thick 
       -Location "Production" -FullClone

# Linked clone example
New-VM -Name "DevTest_Web_001" -VM "TemplateWS2019" 
       -Datastore "Local-SSD" -LinkedClone 
       -ReferenceSnapshot "CleanInstall"

Important operational notes:

  • Linked clones become invalid if parent VM/snapshot is deleted
  • Full clones require complete storage allocation upfront
  • Conversion between types is possible but often time-consuming