LVM vs LUN: Technical Comparison of Storage Virtualization Layers for Linux Systems


12 views

At first glance, both LVM (Logical Volume Manager) and LUN (Logical Unit Number) appear to provide storage abstraction, but they operate at fundamentally different layers:

  • LVM is a software-based storage virtualization implemented at the operating system level (typically in Linux)
  • LUN is a logical storage unit presented by storage hardware (SAN, NAS, or storage arrays)

Here's a technical breakdown of how each technology is structured:

// Example LVM structure in Linux
$ sudo pvcreate /dev/sdb1
$ sudo vgcreate myvg /dev/sdb1
$ sudo lvcreate -L 10G -n mylv myvg
$ sudo mkfs.ext4 /dev/myvg/mylv

In contrast, LUNs are typically configured at the storage controller level:

# iSCSI target configuration example (targetcli)
/> cd /backstores/block
/backstores/block> create lun0 /dev/sdc
/backstores/block> cd /iscsi
/iscsi> create iqn.2023-04.com.example:storage.target
Feature LVM LUN
Abstraction Level OS-level Storage hardware-level
Management Interface CLI tools (lvcreate, vgdisplay) Storage controller GUI/CLI
Snapshots Supported (lvcreate --snapshot) Vendor-dependent
Thin Provisioning Available (--thin) Common in enterprise arrays

When to use LVM:

  • Single server storage management
  • Dynamic volume resizing
  • Creating RAID-like redundancy with mirroring
  • Snapshot-based backups

When to use LUN:

  • Shared storage in SAN environments
  • Multi-server access to same storage
  • Storage array features (deduplication, compression)
  • Enterprise storage provisioning

In enterprise environments, you might combine both technologies:

# On storage array (LUN creation)
1. Create 500GB LUN on storage controller
2. Present to host via iSCSI/FC

# On Linux host (LVM setup)
$ sudo pvcreate /dev/sdX
$ sudo vgcreate sanvg /dev/sdX
$ sudo lvcreate -L 200G -n dbvol sanvg
$ sudo mkfs.xfs /dev/sanvg/dbvol

When working with storage systems in Linux environments, two fundamental virtualization technologies often come into play: LVM (Logical Volume Manager) and LUN (Logical Unit Number). While both create abstraction layers above physical disks, they operate at different levels of the storage stack.

A LUN represents a logical storage unit presented by a storage array or SAN (Storage Area Network). In code, you might interact with LUNs like this:

# Listing available LUNs on a Linux system
ls -l /dev/disk/by-id/scsi-*

Key characteristics of LUNs:

  • Created and managed at the storage array level
  • Appears as a physical disk to the host OS
  • Typically used in enterprise SAN environments

LVM operates at the operating system level, providing flexibility in managing disk space. Here's a basic LVM setup example:

# Creating a physical volume
pvcreate /dev/sdb

# Creating a volume group
vgcreate my_vg /dev/sdb

# Creating a logical volume
lvcreate -L 10G -n my_lv my_vg

LVM offers features like:

  • Dynamic volume resizing
  • Snapshot capabilities
  • Striping and mirroring
Feature LUN LVM
Abstraction Level Storage hardware/array Operating system
Management Point Storage administrator System administrator
Typical Use Case Enterprise SAN storage Local disk management

Here's how you might combine both technologies in a real-world scenario:

# First, discover your LUN
multipath -ll

# Then create LVM on top of the LUN
pvcreate /dev/mapper/mpatha
vgcreate san_vg /dev/mapper/mpatha
lvcreate -L 500G -n db_volume san_vg

When stacking LVM on LUNs, be aware of potential performance impacts:

  • Additional abstraction layers may introduce latency
  • Align LVM stripe size with array stripe size
  • Monitor both LUN and LVM performance metrics

For optimal performance in database environments, consider this tuned setup:

# Create striped logical volume across multiple LUNs
lvcreate -i 4 -I 256 -L 2T -n oracle_data san_vg \
/dev/mapper/mpatha /dev/mapper/mpathb \
/dev/mapper/mpathc /dev/mapper/mpathd