LVM vs LUN: Technical Comparison of Storage Virtualization Layers for Linux Systems


2 views

At first glance, both LVM (Logical Volume Manager) and LUN (Logical Unit Number) appear to provide storage abstraction, but they operate at fundamentally different layers:

  • LVM is a software-based storage virtualization implemented at the operating system level (typically in Linux)
  • LUN is a logical storage unit presented by storage hardware (SAN, NAS, or storage arrays)

Here's a technical breakdown of how each technology is structured:

// Example LVM structure in Linux
$ sudo pvcreate /dev/sdb1
$ sudo vgcreate myvg /dev/sdb1
$ sudo lvcreate -L 10G -n mylv myvg
$ sudo mkfs.ext4 /dev/myvg/mylv

In contrast, LUNs are typically configured at the storage controller level:

# iSCSI target configuration example (targetcli)
/> cd /backstores/block
/backstores/block> create lun0 /dev/sdc
/backstores/block> cd /iscsi
/iscsi> create iqn.2023-04.com.example:storage.target
Feature LVM LUN
Abstraction Level OS-level Storage hardware-level
Management Interface CLI tools (lvcreate, vgdisplay) Storage controller GUI/CLI
Snapshots Supported (lvcreate --snapshot) Vendor-dependent
Thin Provisioning Available (--thin) Common in enterprise arrays

When to use LVM:

  • Single server storage management
  • Dynamic volume resizing
  • Creating RAID-like redundancy with mirroring
  • Snapshot-based backups

When to use LUN:

  • Shared storage in SAN environments
  • Multi-server access to same storage
  • Storage array features (deduplication, compression)
  • Enterprise storage provisioning

In enterprise environments, you might combine both technologies:

# On storage array (LUN creation)
1. Create 500GB LUN on storage controller
2. Present to host via iSCSI/FC

# On Linux host (LVM setup)
$ sudo pvcreate /dev/sdX
$ sudo vgcreate sanvg /dev/sdX
$ sudo lvcreate -L 200G -n dbvol sanvg
$ sudo mkfs.xfs /dev/sanvg/dbvol

When working with storage systems in Linux environments, two fundamental virtualization technologies often come into play: LVM (Logical Volume Manager) and LUN (Logical Unit Number). While both create abstraction layers above physical disks, they operate at different levels of the storage stack.

A LUN represents a logical storage unit presented by a storage array or SAN (Storage Area Network). In code, you might interact with LUNs like this:

# Listing available LUNs on a Linux system
ls -l /dev/disk/by-id/scsi-*

Key characteristics of LUNs:

  • Created and managed at the storage array level
  • Appears as a physical disk to the host OS
  • Typically used in enterprise SAN environments

LVM operates at the operating system level, providing flexibility in managing disk space. Here's a basic LVM setup example:

# Creating a physical volume
pvcreate /dev/sdb

# Creating a volume group
vgcreate my_vg /dev/sdb

# Creating a logical volume
lvcreate -L 10G -n my_lv my_vg

LVM offers features like:

  • Dynamic volume resizing
  • Snapshot capabilities
  • Striping and mirroring
Feature LUN LVM
Abstraction Level Storage hardware/array Operating system
Management Point Storage administrator System administrator
Typical Use Case Enterprise SAN storage Local disk management

Here's how you might combine both technologies in a real-world scenario:

# First, discover your LUN
multipath -ll

# Then create LVM on top of the LUN
pvcreate /dev/mapper/mpatha
vgcreate san_vg /dev/mapper/mpatha
lvcreate -L 500G -n db_volume san_vg

When stacking LVM on LUNs, be aware of potential performance impacts:

  • Additional abstraction layers may introduce latency
  • Align LVM stripe size with array stripe size
  • Monitor both LUN and LVM performance metrics

For optimal performance in database environments, consider this tuned setup:

# Create striped logical volume across multiple LUNs
lvcreate -i 4 -I 256 -L 2T -n oracle_data san_vg \
/dev/mapper/mpatha /dev/mapper/mpathb \
/dev/mapper/mpathc /dev/mapper/mpathd