Java.exe vs Javaw.exe: Key Differences for Windows Server Applications


2 views

When working with Java applications on Windows Server, you'll encounter two primary executable variants:

java.exe   // Runs with a console window
javaw.exe  // Runs without a console window

The fundamental difference lies in how these executables handle the console window:

  • java.exe: Allocates a console window for standard I/O operations (System.out, System.err)
  • javaw.exe: Designed specifically for GUI applications, doesn't create console window

Consider these common use cases:

// Running a server application that logs to file
javaw.exe -jar myServerApp.jar

// Running a console-based utility
java.exe -jar consoleTool.jar

Key behavioral characteristics:

Feature java.exe javaw.exe
Console Window Visible Hidden
Standard I/O Available Redirected to parent process
Process Tree Appears with console Appears as standalone process

For Windows Server deployments:

  • Use javaw.exe for:
    • Background services
    • GUI applications
    • When console output isn't needed
  • Use java.exe for:
    • Command-line tools
    • When you need to see console output
    • Debugging purposes

Here's how you might implement a service wrapper:

@echo off
REM Choose the appropriate launcher based on requirements
if "%1" == "console" (
    java.exe -Xmx1024m -jar MyService.jar
) else (
    javaw.exe -Xmx1024m -jar MyService.jar
)

Common issues and solutions:

  1. Missing console output: Switch from javaw to java for debugging
  2. Unexpected process termination: Check if parent process terminates javaw instance
  3. Memory settings: Both executables accept same JVM arguments

Both java.exe and javaw.exe are Java application launchers included in the Java Development Kit (JDK), but they serve different purposes in Windows environments:

  • java.exe: Launches Java applications with a visible console window and standard I/O streams
  • javaw.exe: Launches Java applications without a console window (the "w" stands for "windowless")

Here's when to choose each launcher:

// For command-line applications needing console interaction:
java.exe -jar MyConsoleApp.jar

// For GUI applications or background services:
javaw.exe -jar MySwingApp.jar

The choice between them affects several aspects:

Aspect java.exe javaw.exe
Console Window Visible Hidden
System Tray Icon Creates Java icon No icon by default
Error Output Shows in console Requires logging

When running multiple instances:

// java.exe creates distinct console windows for each instance
start java.exe -jar App1.jar
start java.exe -jar App2.jar

// javaw.exe runs quietly in background
start javaw.exe -jar Service1.jar
start javaw.exe -jar Service2.jar

For development, java.exe is generally better because:

  • Immediate visibility of System.out/err
  • Easier to terminate (Ctrl+C in console)
  • Stack traces appear directly in console

For production GUI apps, javaw.exe is preferable to avoid:

// This would create an unnecessary console for a Swing app
java.exe -jar MyGUIApp.jar

On Windows Servers, consider these factors:

  • Use javaw.exe for Windows services (via wrapper tools)
  • java.exe is better for batch processing with logging
  • Memory usage is identical between both