Strategies for Scaling LTO-3 Tape Backups in Enterprise Environments: Hardware Upgrades and Workflow Optimization


4 views

When your LTO-3 tape backups start spanning multiple tapes (surpassing the 400GB native/800GB compressed capacity), you're facing fundamental infrastructure limitations. The pain points become particularly acute in environments running Backup Exec 12.x/13.x with Server 2003/2008 and Exchange workloads.

Key observations from real-world backup metrics:

// Sample backup throughput measurements (MB/min)
Exchange Server C:       600 MB/min  
Fileserver G:           2400 MB/min
Accounting SQL:         1600 MB/min
Backup Server E:        2900 MB/min

The performance variance across servers reveals fundamental I/O limitations, especially with older hardware using consumer-grade SATA drives.

Option 1: Parallel LTO-3 Drives (Not Recommended)
While adding a second LTO-3 drive provides immediate relief, it's a dead-end solution given LTO-3's technological obsolescence.

Option 2: LTO-4 Migration Strategy
Sample PowerShell script to manage mixed LTO-3/4 media:

# PowerShell script for Backup Exec media management
$LTO3Pool = Get-BEMediaPool -Name "LTO3_Differentials"
$LTO4Pool = Get-BEMediaPool -Name "LTO4_FullBackups"

Set-BEJob -Name "WeeklyFull" -MediaPool $LTO4Pool
Set-BEJob -Name "DailyDiff" -MediaPool $LTO3Pool

Option 3: Autoloader Implementation
For enterprise environments, autoloaders like the Dell TL2000 (LTO-4) provide:

  • 8-slot capacity (6.4TB native)
  • SAS 6Gb/s connectivity
  • Robotic media handling

To calculate and minimize tape waste:

// SQL query to analyze Backup Exec media usage
SELECT 
   MediaName,
   (UsedCapacity - DataSize) AS WastedSpace,
   ((UsedCapacity - DataSize)/UsedCapacity)*100 AS WastePercentage
FROM 
   BEMedia 
WHERE 
   Compression = 'OFF'
ORDER BY 
   WastePercentage DESC;

Upgrade paths for backup servers:

Component Current Recommended
NIC Single 1GbE Dual 10GbE or 4x1GbE LACP
Controller Ultra160 SCSI SAS 6Gb/s HBA
Cache Typically 16MB 1GB+ write cache

Sample migration plan:

  1. Week 1-2: Benchmark current environment
  2. Week 3: Procure LTO-4 hardware
  3. Week 4: Parallel testing phase
  4. Week 5: Full cutover

Remember to maintain LTO-3 capability during transition for differential backups.


html

When your full backups exceed LTO-3's 400GB native capacity (372.5GB usable), the workflow breaks down. My environment with Backup Exec 12.x/13.x on Server 2003/2008 plus Exchange hits this wall regularly. The current single-drive process forces:

  • Manual tape swaps mid-backup (6+ hour penalty)
  • Verification bottlenecks (2 additional tape handlings)
  • Weekend monitoring requirements

Throughput metrics reveal infrastructure limitations:

// Sample backup speeds (MB/min)
Exchange Storage Group: 700
Fileserver G:          2400
Accounting SQL:        2250
Backup Server E:       2900

Note the RAID controller bottleneck (SATA 1.5 vs 3.0 drives) limiting potential gains.

Three viable solutions emerge from testing:

Option 1: LTO-4 Drive Migration

Spec comparison:

Spec LTO-3 LTO-4
Native Capacity 400GB 800GB
Min Speed 40MB/s 30MB/s
Compressed Speed 160MB/s 240MB/s

Implementation script for Backup Exec:

# PowerShell tape media pool migration
$LTO3Pool = Get-BEMediaPool -Name "LTO3_Full"
$LTO4Pool = New-BEMediaPool -Name "LTO4_Full" -MediaType "LTO-4"

# Transition plan
Get-BEJob | Where {$_.MediaPool -eq $LTO3Pool} | 
    Set-BEJob -MediaPool $LTO4Pool -Verbose

Option 2: Autoloader Implementation

Cost-benefit analysis of Dell TL2000 (LTO-4):

  • Base unit: $4,200
  • Slots: 8
  • Robotic load time: 25s

Backup Exec autoloader configuration:

// Device configuration XML snippet
<StorageDevice>
  <Library Type="Autoloader">
    <Drive Slot="1" Barcode="TL2000-001"/>
    <Inventory>
      <Media Slot="2" Label="FULL_01"/>
      <Media Slot="3" Label="DIFF_01"/>
    </Inventory>
  </Library>
</StorageDevice>

Actual capacity loss measured via:

Backup Exec SQL Query:
SELECT MediaLabel, UsedCapacityGB, DataGB, 
       (UsedCapacityGB-DataGB) AS WastedGB
FROM MediaTable
WHERE MediaType = 'LTO3' AND Compression = 'OFF'

Typical results showed 5-15% capacity loss from speed mismatches.

The LSI SAS controller upgrade demonstrated:

  • 35% faster verification cycles
  • Reduced shoe-shining by 8%
  • Consistent 210MB/s sustained writes

Driver configuration example:

# Linux tape driver tuning
modprobe st buffer_kbs=2048
echo "options sg tape_buffer_size=65536" > /etc/modprobe.d/tape.conf

For the 6-year-old Exchange 2003 server:

// ESEUTIL backup throttling
eseutil /k "Q:\Backup\Monday.edb" /t "T:\Tape\Exchange.edb" 
        /d /8 /p /256

This reduced backup time by 22% despite legacy hardware.

Recommended phased approach:

  1. Immediate: Migrate largest datasets to LTO-4
  2. 30 Days: Implement SAS HBA upgrade
  3. 60 Days: Evaluate autoloader ROI
  4. Ongoing: Monitor shoeshining via SQL query