When dealing with multiple Windows machines in an enterprise environment or during software deployment, verifying consistent directory structures and permissions becomes crucial. A common pain point emerges when:

• Driver updates modify ACLs unexpectedly
• File deployments miss critical permission settings
• Security policies create inconsistent access controls

For quick comparisons without third-party tools, PowerShell provides powerful capabilities:

# Basic directory comparison with hashes
$sourceFiles = Get-ChildItem -Recurse C:\source\path
$destFiles = Get-ChildItem -Recurse \\remote\path
Compare-Object $sourceFiles $destFiles -Property Name, Length, LastWriteTime

# NTFS permission comparison
Function Compare-FolderPermissions {
    param(
        [string]$Path1,
        [string]$Path2
    )
    $acl1 = Get-Acl $Path1
    $acl2 = Get-Acl $Path2
    return Compare-Object $acl1.Access $acl2.Access -Property IdentityReference, FileSystemRights
}

# Example usage:
Compare-FolderPermissions -Path1 "C:\Program Files\App" -Path2 "\\server\C$\Program Files\App"

Microsoft's built-in Robocopy offers verbose comparison capabilities:

robocopy C:\source \\remote\destination /L /X /E /ZB /COPY:DATSOU /LOG:comparison.log /TEE /NP /R:0 /W:0

Key switches:

• /L - List-only mode (no actual copying)
• /COPY:DATSOU - Compare Data, Attributes, Timestamps, Security, Owner, Auditing info
• /X - Report all extra files (not just differing ones)

For integration into deployment tools or custom solutions:

using System.IO;
using System.Security.AccessControl;

public class PermissionComparer
{
    public void CompareDirectories(string dir1, string dir2)
    {
        var dir1ACL = Directory.GetAccessControl(dir1);
        var dir2ACL = Directory.GetAccessControl(dir2);
        
        // Compare access rules
        var rules1 = dir1ACL.GetAccessRules(true, true, typeof(System.Security.Principal.NTAccount));
        var rules2 = dir2ACL.GetAccessRules(true, true, typeof(System.Security.Principal.NTAccount));
        
        // Implementation for detailed comparison would go here
    }
}

For GUI-based solutions consider:

• AccessEnum (Sysinternals) - Lightweight permission snapshot tool
• Beyond Compare - Commercial tool with permission comparison
• TreeComp - Specialized in folder structure analysis

Sample script for build pipelines:

# PowerShell script for Azure DevOps
$expectedAcl = Get-Acl "C:\reference\permissions"
$targetAcl = Get-Acl $(Build.ArtifactStagingDirectory)

$diff = Compare-Object $expectedAcl.Access $targetAcl.Access -Property IdentityReference, FileSystemRights
if ($diff) {
    Write-Error "Permission mismatch detected!"
    $diff | Format-Table -AutoSize
    exit 1
}

When troubleshooting:

1. Always check inherited vs explicit permissions separately
2. Compare effective permissions (use whoami /priv)
3. Remember that SYSTEM and admin permissions may differ
4. Account for UAC virtualization in Program Files

---

When troubleshooting Windows system issues, comparing directory structures and NTFS permissions between machines is a common but surprisingly complex task. Standard file comparison tools like WinMerge focus primarily on file contents rather than metadata, leaving administrators without a clear way to audit permission differences programmatically.

Windows PowerShell provides native capabilities for comparing both directory structures and permissions. Here's a comprehensive script that outputs differences in a machine-readable format:

# Compare directories and permissions between two paths
$sourcePath = "\\Machine1\C$\Program Files\App"
$targetPath = "\\Machine2\C$\Program Files\App"
$outputFile = "C:\Temp\PermissionDiff.txt"

function Get-PermissionHash {
    param ($path)
    Get-ChildItem $path -Recurse | ForEach-Object {
        $acl = Get-Acl $_.FullName
        [PSCustomObject]@{
            Path = $_.FullName
            Permissions = $acl.Access | 
                Select-Object IdentityReference, FileSystemRights, AccessControlType
            LastWriteTime = $_.LastWriteTime
            Attributes = $_.Attributes
        }
    }
}

$sourceData = Get-PermissionHash $sourcePath
$targetData = Get-PermissionHash $targetPath

Compare-Object $sourceData $targetData -Property Path,Permissions,LastWriteTime,Attributes |
    Where-Object { $_.SideIndicator -eq "<=" } | 
    Export-Csv $outputFile -NoTypeInformation

For quick structural comparisons, Robocopy's logging feature can identify missing files:

robocopy "\\Machine1\C$\Program Files\App" "\\Machine2\C$\Program Files\App" /L /X /XD /E /NP /LOG:C:\Temp\DirDiff.txt

For enterprise environments, these tools provide advanced comparison capabilities:

• Beyond Compare (with Pro version's ACL comparison)
• SetACL Studio - Specialized for permission auditing
• TreeSize Professional - Includes permission reporting

Once differences are identified, you can use icacls to synchronize permissions:

# Export permissions from reference machine
icacls "C:\Program Files\App\*" /save permExport.txt /t /c

# Apply to target machine
icacls "C:\Program Files\App" /restore permExport.txt

Remember to account for:

• Inherited vs explicit permissions
• Local vs domain accounts (SID resolution)
• System-reserved directories requiring TrustedInstaller access